There are a few non-Argo fans who feel he doesn't deserve All-Argo status since he only played 2 seasons, as well as not deserving to be recognized as the greatest Argos QB in history. Good timing to add Flutie with reunion in town but what about Dicky Thornton?

https://www.cfl.ca/2017/07/17/flutie-named-time-argo/