Quote Originally Posted by R.J View Post
Noted, but the statement that Maher is more erratic compared to Waters is just plain false.
I did say it was my perception. I recall Maher being quite erratic in 2014 and also late in the 2016 season with Hamilton after playing well for much of that season. After looking at the stats, it isn't like Maher has been better than Waters. Waters has the edge in both FG percentage (however slight) and punting average.