Jason Barnes

[Will]

Way for him to step it up tonight and get the TD when we needed it! I seem to recall someone wanting to cut Barnes after his performance last week.

It's just one game, but I think he's starting to answer his critics.

Boyd is awesome, Inman is the go to guy with Durie while Barnes and Pre were horrible and should be cut.

Barnes is done.

[KCargosfan]

haha, maybe a bit of a knee-jerk reaction there from someone.

[ArgoGabe22]

If argotom was the GM we would have no one on our team because they would all be cut.

[Argoscflguy]

Barnes showed some good hands, good speed and I thought that grab from ray was a good way for him to stamp his name in Argos football for years to come! Shout out for durie!!!!!! Great Canadian player!

[AngeloV]

Way for him to step it up tonight and get the TD when we needed it! I seem to recall someone wanting to cut Barnes after his performance last week.

It's just one game, but I think he's starting to answer his critics.

Exactly. Of course, I am starting to get numb to all the ridiculous knee jerk after game reactions on here now.

Having said that, I must apologize for my comment last week about binging back Robert Baker to "finish the job" on Pre. I was joking, but some may not have taken it that way.

[matchuk]

wonder what they are gonna do when mo mann is ready to return?

[AngeloV]

wonder what they are gonna do when mo mann is ready to return?

He's ready. They just can't find a spot for him now.

[matchuk]

He's ready. They just can't find a spot for him now.

ah, didnt know that...thanks...

[argotom]

Way for him to step it up tonight and get the TD when we needed it! I seem to recall someone wanting to cut Barnes after his performance last week.

It's just one game, but I think he's starting to answer his critics.

Yes that was me and I do stand by my then earlier decision.
Although after yesterday I am willing to give him one more chance!

If argotom was the GM we would have no one on our team because they would all be cut.

Give me a chance AG22.
Having said that, we certainly would never had and dare I bring up his name again, Lemon on our roster.

[AngeloV]

Give me a chance AG22.
Having said that, we certainly would never had and dare I bring up his name again, Lemon on our roster.

Because all other options at the time were just so much better.

[1argoholic]

I think Barnes has shown to be one tough player with no fear to into heavy traffic. That catch against Calgary was amazing. He played well last night and he got a beautiful diving catch against Hamilton over turned by the drunk Jake Ireland. Jake has to be replaced on Argo games.

[argotom]

Because all other options at the time were just so much better.

You are kidding right?
Without rehashing the obvious, there were literally dozens of options available to Barker with each one better then Lemon.
In fact, Prefontaine as a QB is better.
There is nothing like history to prove me and others correct, who echoed the same opinion.

[paulwoods13]

You are kidding right?
Without rehashing the obvious, there were literally dozens of options available to Barker with each one better then Lemon.
In fact, Prefontaine as a QB is better.
There is nothing like history to prove me and others correct, who echoed the same opinion.

Honestly, argotom, no one is arguing Lemon was a good QB but "literally dozens" of better options? Would you mind listing the first 25 or 30 so we can all marvel? And don't include Pre because that's just hyperbole.

[AngeloV]

You are kidding right?
Without rehashing the obvious, there were literally dozens of options available to Barker with each one better then Lemon.
In fact, Prefontaine as a QB is better.
There is nothing like history to prove me and others correct, who echoed the same opinion.

No. I would never kid you.

[argotom]

Honestly, argotom, no one is arguing Lemon was a good QB but "literally dozens" of better options? Would you mind listing the first 25 or 30 so we can all marvel? And don't include Pre because that's just hyperbole.

No PW, I am serious even recent guys that retired from the league or Canadian QB's graduating from the CIS would have been better options.
As for Lemon being a "good QB" as you put it, he wasn't even tolerable.
History has proved that.
Let's not beat a dead horse.

[Fungi]

We win a game so every one gangs up on Argotom to celerate our win. Who's stirring the pot here? Can you stop?
Go Argo's.
You're a good fan Argotom.

[paulwoods13]

No PW, I am serious even recent guys that retired from the league or Canadian QB's graduating from the CIS would have been better options.
As for Lemon being a "good QB" as you put it, he wasn't even tolerable.
History has proved that.
Let's not beat a dead horse.

OK, you are apparently serious in your belief that there were "literally dozens" of QBs better than Lemon available to the Argos. I asked you to name at least two dozen so that we could ponder whether they all truly would have been better than Lemon. I'm not arguing Lemon was or wasn't a good QB -- I'm arguing it's beyond mere hyperbole to say they were "literally dozens" of guys who would have been better AND were available to the Argos. Tell you what, I will reduce my request -- how be you just name one dozen?

[1argoholic]

Let's start talking about Bishop as well. I'll just say both shite qb's that I'm sick of hearing about. We have Ricky Ray who shows what a great CFL qb is all about. Lemon was a lemon. I would have rather seen Pre at qb.

[argotom]

We win a game so every one gangs up on Argotom to celerate our win. Who's stirring the pot here? Can you stop?
Go Argo's.
You're a good fan Argotom.

Thanks, likewise Fungi.

[argolio]

Since the topic here is now Lemon, I'll stir some more....

Whatever one has to say about Lemon's on-field performance, he was clearly our best QB coming out of two straight training camps, we won a playoff game in Hamilton, he was a great team guy up until that infamous halftime (which he arguably was justified in being angry at getting pulled in a game where we were only down by 7), and he helped bridge the gap from Bart Andrus to Milanovich & Ricky Ray. On balance I'll take that and thank him for his time as an Argo.

Then when Lemon was released and Jyles became the starter, he put up worse 2011 numbers than Lemon, yet I never saw anywhere near the same criticism for Jyles around here as there was for Lemon. Very strange.